Deciding Which DIY Skin Care Products to Sell Online

There are successful makers that settled on DIY skin care products to sell online simply by trial and error.

Make and list *this* product, see if it sells. Make and list *that* product, see if it sells.

While this method can work…eventually…if you’re lucky…it is by no means the fastest or most cost efficient way to develop a product line that your target market will flock to.

The top beauty and skin care companies spend unbelievable amounts of time and money on market research before production.

As handmade sellers, we do not have those resources available for product research.

So…how do WE decide which of our DIY skin care products to sell online…without simply throwing spaghetti at the wall?

This article is going to walk you through six CALCULATED steps you can take as a skin care maker to ensure you are making the best decisions possible for your handmade product line.

DIY Skin Care Products to Sell Online Featured Image

6 Steps to Deciding Which DIY Skin Care Products to Sell Online

Before dipping our toes into the product selection process, it is absolutely ESSENTIAL that you have identified a specific target market for your business.

There is no way you can begin to choose which products will sell well in your shop without knowing exactly who you will be selling to.

You want to have EVERYTHING about your ideal customer in mind as you compile a possible product list in the steps below:

  • age
  • gender
  • economic status
  • geographic location
  • education
  • lifestyle, etc.

Once you know your super specific target audience, get out a piece of paper and write it at the very top…

E.g., The vintage grunge college student, the new crunchy mommy, the retired urbanite, etc.

Example skin care target market to guide making a product list

Step 1: List Current Products

Write down every product that you currently make.

If you don’t have a product line yet, write down every recipe that you’ve been imagining and brainstorming for your future business.

Be sure to write down every variation of product. For example, instead of just writing ‘lip balm’, write down every scent of lip balm you create: lavender lime lip balm, orange ginger lip balm, spiced chai lip balm.

Current products for a handmade skin care line

Step 2: Check ‘Ready’ Products

Put a checkmark next to the products that are 100% ready to go and fit perfectly with your chosen target market.

Checkmark next to skin care products to sell online

Step 3: Circle ‘Modifiable’ Products

Take another look at the products you did NOT check in Step 2.

Are there any that would fit with your target market if they were changed a bit (either the ingredients, the name of the product, the way it is used, etc.)?

Based on your target market, could you…

  • Make that hand salve into a tattoo salve?
  • Turn that anti-aging eye cream into a postpartum skin care cream?

Take notes on the changes you have in mind!

Circled skin care products to modify for target market

Step 4: Ditch Products

Go through your current products/ideas list one last time and completely cross off the items that do NOT fit with your current target market.

Eliminating skin care products that will not be part of future online sales

Free Natural Skin Care Recipe Book

Over 60 recipes to make and sell online - face serum, eye cream, lip balm, belly balm, soap, +++!

Free Natural Skin Care Recipe Book

Step 5: Research New DIY Skin Care Products to Sell Online

After completing the first four steps, you may find that you want to add more products to make your line feel ‘full’.

Keep in mind that you don’t need hundreds of listings. You can keep a very small product list but still appear to have a larger inventory by creating bundles and gift sets. Sometimes less is more!

If you want to add more types of products, the three basic market research tools that we’ll cover next work well and are super easy to use.

Using Etsy for Market Research

Even if you don’t intend to sell on Etsy, their platform makes it easy to see what products are trending and popular.

Go to

In the search bar, type in a broad keyword/product category based on your target market.

Searching for key words in Etsy relevant to target market

This will populate products from many different shops that fall under that keyword/category.

Find a product that you are interested in making yourself that has 5 black stars and more than 500 reviews.

Finding a skin care product that fits with your target market

Click on the shop name.

(Sometimes that brings you to that specific product and not the entire storefront for that seller. Simply click on the shop name again until you see all of their products at once.)

Look for items that have red text underneath that say, “Over ‘x’ people have this in their cart” – this should be a red flag about which products could potentially be a slam dunk for your own line.

Circling items that will fit well in your own skin care product line

Write down any product ideas on your paper to keep in mind.

Note that we are getting inspiration from other stores – you will need to come up with your own formulations, product names, and descriptions. This is just good ole market research!

Rinse and repeat until you have a list of new product ideas that are relevant to your target market.

Creating a list of new skin care product ideas to sell online

Using Google for Market Research

Go to

In the search bar, type in the same phrase that you did in the Etsy Market Research tutorial above.

Using Google to research diy skin care product ideas to sell online

Click on the ‘Images’ tab and scroll through to see if it generates any ideas for you. The images will be sprinkled with Pinterest and blog posts, but it can get ideas rolling.

Images generated from a Google search

Go back to the general search (click the ‘all’ tab at the top of the page).

Scroll down to the very bottom of the screen.

You will see a section that says, “Searches related to…”

These are all of the TOP searched phrases that have to do with the keyword you put in the search bar above (read: GOLDMINE).

These terms should give you a flood of new ideas for skin care products and gift sets that your target market would love to see in your online shop.

Write any appealing ideas down on your skin care product list.

Using Searches Relating To on Google to find skin care product ideas

Using Google Trends to Validate Product Ideas

The last tool we’ll explore in our basic market research is Google Trends.

This site lets you see what terms are being searched for the most on Google.

Make sure you have your target market’s demographic information and your product idea list for this exercise.

Go to

Type in one of the main product category ideas on your list.

For our example purposes, we’ll be using the keyword ‘face serum’.

Searching for Face Serum in Google Trends

When you hit enter, your search term will appear in the top left, as well as FOUR important drop down menus beneath it.

Make sure the first drop down is toggled to your target market’s geographic location.

The timeframe drop down should be toggled to Past 5 Years.

The last two should be set on All Categories and Web Search.

As you can see in the image below, the resulting line graph shows that face serum has been trending UP over the last five years in the United States, with New York being the most interested subregion.

Google Trends Report showing face serum trending up

Do a search for all of the skin care product ideas on your list.

The goal is to find products that are either staying CONSISTENT or TRENDING UP.

An amazing research tool, right??

You can also use Google Trends to compare different products on your list if you need to narrow them down.

On the tab (to the right your first keyword) that says ‘Compare’, type in another product idea.

For our example purposes, we’ll be comparing face serum to lip balm.

This will give you two line graphs simultaneously (keep scrolling for visual).

As you can see in the chart below, more people search for the phrase ‘lip balm’ than they do ‘face serum’.

You can also see that lip balm is a very seasonal item: the peaks that I have circled in pink are ALL the month of December.

Side note: Notice how ‘flat’ the face serum line graph looks in this screenshot compared to the first one by itself. It is very important to do these searches individually to get the full picture.

Comparing two product ideas in Google Trends

Free Natural Skin Care Recipe Book

Over 60 recipes to make and sell online - face serum, eye cream, lip balm, belly balm, soap, +++!

Free Natural Skin Care Recipe Book

Step 6: Finalize your entire DIY Skin Care Product List to Sell Online

Have a list of ALL products you would like to create from steps 1-5 above.

Look at each product and ask yourself (based on research):

1. Is this something that your target market needs or wants?

If you already have a social media following or other accessible audience, ASK THEM! Polls are incredibly popular (and engaging)!

2. Do you have a good balance of EVERGREEN items vs TREND items?

BEWARE of hinging your entire brand on one trend. Could your business still stand and profit when trends change?

3. Do your chosen products make sense from a business standpoint?

We’re talking about profit margin, amount of time the product(s) take to make, acceptable shelf life. Etc.

If your products check all of these boxes, add them to the last column on your worksheet, ‘final product list’

List of final diy skin care products to sell online
And that’s it!

CONGRATULATIONS on taking the time to do some digging to find the products that will speak RIGHT to your target market (so much better than the spaghetti-at-the-wall method!).

Now, get ready to tackle all of the branding details that will make your skin care product line stand out even MORE to your target audience.

The DIY Skin Care Business Branding Guide will walk you through step ONE to step SIXTEEN (launching your line on any e-commerce site):

Spread some love by pinning this to your business branding and diy skin care Pinterest boards!

Products to Make and Sell for Your DIY Skin Care Business

Related Posts:

Naming Your Skin Care Business Featured Image
How to Choose a Color Palette for Your Skin Care Business, text on top of a stack of color swatches
Author, Christine Glaser
Author, Christine Glaser

Organic Skin Care Formulator, Skin Care Business Coach

Christine has spent the last decade making and selling natural skin care products on Etsy, Shopify, Woocommerce, Wix, Squarespace, +++. She is passionate about teaching other makers in the handmade industry how to build and grow successful businesses from home.

Christine Glaser, owner of DIY Skin Care Business and DIY Skin Care Mompreneur

Hey there, I’m Christine.

I teach creative natural-living-lovers how to build handmade skin care businesses from their homes…

…on a part-time schedule…without the overwhelm.

Let’s work together to spread the importance of chemical-free living!


Best Instagram Hashtags Featured Image
How to Use a Content Calendar for your Skin Care Business
114 diy skin care social media ideas
How to Make Organic Lip Balm to Sell Online
Identify Your Winning Target Market as a Handmade Seller
Skin Care and Beauty Holidays for Social Media
Naming Your Skin Care Business Featured Image
Shop Great Certified USDA Organic Oils at Plant Therapy!

Popular Products

Social Media Content Calendar for Skin Care Makers
Skin Care Business Blueprint
Researched Instagram Hashtags for Skin Care Entrepreneurs